About Us     |     Join PAN    |     Donate
large pesticide container
Picture of Rob Faux

Rob Faux

SCOTUS gave pesticide companies immunity. There is still a better path forward.

Perhaps you haven’t heard. Or maybe it was lost amidst a host of other news that has grabbed your attention in recent months. The Supreme Court granted lawsuit immunity to large, multinational pesticide companies.

The Supreme Court of the United States sided with Monsanto (Bayer) in a court case that effectively removed the only useful tool individuals had to keep pesticide companies accountable. The case was found in favor of Monsanto in a 7-2 vote in June. Majority opinions were submitted by Justices Kavanaugh and Thomas. Justice Jackson submitted a dissenting opinion.

Simply put, this decision provides pesticide companies with a liability shield that prevents people like you and me from seeking accountability when a pesticide product can be shown to have harmed us.

Bayer/Monsanto working hard for lawsuit immunity

Bayer (Monsanto) has been seeking to pass laws in numerous states since 2024 that would provide lawsuit immunity for pesticide companies in those states. At the same time, they have been seeking to include language in several federal bills that would both provide legal immunity for pesticide companies and prevent states and localities from having stronger pesticide regulations than those set by the EPA.

But the pressure doesn’t stop there. Bayer has also been pushing the EPA to implement rules in ways that favor agribusiness even more than they do now. They even influenced the President of the United States who issued an executive order listing glyphosate as a product that is “critical for national defense.”

What Bayer didn’t expect was the grassroots resistance in states like Idaho, Missouri and Iowa (among others). Bills failed in all but a few states thanks to a growing understanding of the intent of these proposed laws. Similarly, several sections of the Federal Farm Bill were removed thanks to public opposition. Nationally, politicians are beginning to recognize that the public doesn’t want them to hand pesticide companies a license to deceive.

Meanwhile, Monsanto v Durnell was working its way through the courts. This case started in a Missouri state court in 2019 when John Durnell alleged that his non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma had been caused by a 20-year history of using RoundupTM products. In order to win, Durnell had to show that these products were the cause of his illness. He also had to show that Monsanto/Bayer knew about the risk but failed to warn him (and others who used the product) of the potential for harm.

Failure to warn lawsuits are notoriously difficult to win. Yet, Durnell won a $1.25 million dollar settlement. This decision was upheld when the case was appealed to higher level courts.

Until this Supreme Court ruling.

Federal bills introduced seeking to address Durnell case

The Supreme Court ruling made it clear that the biggest issue with our current FIFRA (Federal Insecticide, Fungicide and Rodenticide Act) is that it leaves too much room for interpretation. While two justices clearly understood how FIFRA was interpreted and implemented by the EPA, seven of them did not. As a result, they upended a system that provided an accountability check in state courthouses that had been in place for decades.

Recognizing strong public displeasure with the idea of lawsuit immunity for pesticide companies, several bills have been proposed at the federal level to address this issue. Of these bills, the effort put forward by Representatives Pingree and Massey appears to be the most effective to address this specific problem. The wording is simple, direct and clear. And the bill was informed by experts who understand the workings of FIFRA, state tort law, the EPA and the pesticide registration process.

Of course, it makes sense to support this effort, just as it makes sense to oppose any further efforts to codify lawsuit immunity for pesticide companies or the preemption of stronger state and local regulations.

But all of these are simply defensive actions. While we lost ground after the Durnell case, expending excessive energy to get back to a deeply flawed status quo is missing what could be a golden opportunity.

A way forward after Durnell

Certainly, the decision by the Supreme Court can be further analyzed and we could fire up public opinion to reverse the impacts of the decision through legislation. But I believe this is a time for a bigger action.

More people are becoming aware of the inordinate power that has been granted to multinational agrichemical businesses. At the same time, individuals are struggling with health concerns while research continues to provide evidence showing the link between pesticides and those illnesses. It is becoming clear to all of us that corporations are capturing our food and farming systems for their benefit, leaving people like you and I to suffer the consequences of their actions.

I believe we are remembering our strength as a people united. We want to live lives with clean water, clean air, and safe food produced in healthy soil. And we know that our government is supposed to be serving us, not corporations that are only concerned about how much money and power they can collect for themselves and their top executives.

Here are some suggestions for ways we can make progress:

1. Propose, support and pass laws to ban specific pesticides at the state level.

Already, Vermont has signed a bill into law to ban the dangerous herbicide paraquat and several states are looking at similar bills in the coming year. California’s Department of Pesticide Regulation (DPR) also recently announced that they would be phasing out the use of paraquat.

Meanwhile, there are several other pesticides that have sufficient history of harm that are worthy of similar bills. For example, chlorpyrifos is another product that should no longer be in use.

2. Pass laws that secure the rights of states and local communities to set stronger regulations for pesticide use.

Pesticide companies have been working for a long time to prevent communities from setting stronger regulations. Even though people are generally in favor of rules that would restrict application near schools or important sources of drinking water they are often startled to learn that such actions aren’t possible throughout much of the United States. It’s time to take power back for the people.

3. Let’s get behind a federal bill that would do more—like PACTPA would have.

There was a federal bill proposed earlier this decade called PACTPA that actually addressed a number of the issues that makes our current pesticide regulatory system inadequate. That bill would have banned organophosphate pesticides (like chlorpyrifos), neonicotinoid pesticides and paraquat. But, it also did so much more.

PACTPA would have done the following:

  • Require the listing of inert ingredients, many of which are as dangerous as the active ingredients;
  • Close loopholes that have allowed the EPA to issue emergency exemptions and conditional registrations to use pesticides even before they go through full health and safety reviews;
  • Create a petition process for the people which will allow citizens to request review of pesticides that would otherwise be approved for use indefinitely;
  • Support local community protective actions from preemption of veto by state law;
  • Protect farmworkers from harm by requiring EPA-reviewed injury reports, improved pesticide label instructions and requiring labels in languages in addition to English; and
  • Broaden the knowledge base by requiring suspension and review of pesticides deemed unsafe by other nations.

We could also include language that protects our right to seek accountability through state tort law when we are injured by a pesticide. We could require the analysis of soil health to be part of evaluating a pesticide product. And we could close the loophole that exempts seed treatments from regulation while we’re at it.

I think we’ve got the will. We do not need to settle for a broken pesticide regulatory system. Let’s make the effort to stop playing defense and do this right.

Picture of Rob Faux

Rob Faux

Rob Faux is PAN’s Communications Manager, joining the organization in 2020. He has owned and operated the Genuine Faux Farm near Tripoli, Iowa with his spouse, Tammy, since 2004, growing produce and raising poultry for local sales. They are committed to sustainable growing practices and have maintained organic certification since 2007. In a former life, Rob worked as a software engineer and a post-secondary educator in Computer Science.

Share this post